Shoelace knot
On a tied shoe, the bow crosses its two laces twice, once close to the shoe and once more round two loops. Each stride strikes the knot and swings its loops and ends, and in time one free end slips right through.
Two crossings and two loops
Seen from above, a tied bow has two crossings, each one called a trefoil. The first is tied close to the lacing. The second is tied after it, with each lace folded into a loop. Out of the second crossing come two loops and two free ends. The place where it grips them is the centre of the knot. Fig. 1 puts these names on a bow.
The bow is also called the shoelace knot or the bow knot. A paper of 2017 names it the shoelace bow-tie knot, and some old patents call the laces shoe strings. Wikipedia calls it “a doubly slipped reef knot”. On his website about shoelaces, Ian Fieggen calls it a slipped reef knot. A post on the International Guild of Knot Tyers’ forum, a user report, calls it the slipped reef bend.
That paper began about ten years earlier, when a 4-year-old asked her father why shoelaces come untied. Her father, Oliver O’Reilly, is a professor of mechanical engineering at the University of California at Berkeley. Even after watching YouTube tutorials he could not answer her. In 2014 he brought in two graduate students, Christopher Daily-Diamond and Christine Gregg. Their paper took three years of weekends and spare time, on borrowed equipment.
What one stride does
Each stride works on the knot twice. As the leg swings forward and then back a little to meet the ground, the loops and free ends keep moving, so they pull forward against the knot centre and open it. Then the heel strikes. Its force reaches the knot through the shoe’s tongue and eyelets, and the centre deforms. With the centre open, the friction holding the laces falls, and a free end can slide. What pulls it out is the difference between its own inertia and that of its loop.
The authors measured the strike with a small wireless accelerometer fixed under the knot. In walking it was typically 6 to 8 g, and the authors found it much the same in running shoes, hiking boots, casual sneakers and barefoot shoes. Before testing anything, they had watched a knot that often came undone within about 50 feet of walking. It held when the leg was swung back and forth from a table, with no strike. It held too when the foot was stamped the same number of times. “You can’t seem to get knot failure without both,” Daily-Diamond said.
Walk a shoe tied the paper’s strong way in Fig. 2, one stride at a time. Guess how many strides its bow lasts, and how much of a loop has gone into its free end by the stride before it gives way.
What the drawing shows
The model’s bow lasts 228 strides, and in that time its left free end gains only 21.1 mm, about an eighth of its loop. At stride 229 the end takes the other 144.1 mm at once and comes right through the knot centre. Only the first crossing is left, as on the paper’s runner. Stamping without a swing moves 0.9 mm in 300 strides. Swinging without a strike moves nothing.
Why the end runs out
The authors filmed Gregg, a runner, on a treadmill at 900 frames a second, her shoes tied the weak way. For many strides little changed. Then the knot came undone, often in less than two strides. A footnote in the paper borrows a line from Hemingway’s “The Sun Also Rises” for it: “Two ways. Gradually, then suddenly.”
Their explanation is in the loop and its free end. A free end that slips grows longer and heavier, so the swing pulls it harder. The loop shrinks as the end grows. So the loop pulls back less. Each slip makes the next one easier, until the end overpowers the loop in one or two strides. In the model behind Fig. 2 the lace’s own weight does this. A millimetre of it weighs 1.636 mg, and every millimetre that moves adds its weight to the free end’s pull. It also leaves the loop, which hangs on two strands, so the loop’s pull back falls by half a millimetre’s weight.
A knot on a swinging arm
To test the idea, the authors built a pendulum (Fig. 3). A knot was fixed near the end of an arm about 20 cm long. The arm was let go from about 43 degrees and struck a surface, slowing the knot at about 7 g. That is close to walking. Every knot was tied to a template, with loops and free ends 8.26 cm long, in identical black unwaxed dress laces from a store, 2 mm thick. A trial ran until the knot failed, or for 15 minutes.
Small weights stood in for the swing. The authors hung 1, 2 or 3 g on each free end, 7.4 to 22 times the end’s own mass. With no weight, the strong knots slipped about 0.003 mm per strike. Struck from the rear, only knots with 3 g came completely undone, 8 of 15. Struck from the side, 40% came undone with 2 g. In every test most of the lace moved within a short run of strikes.
The model takes its slip per strike for each weight from the paper’s bar chart, with straight lines between the bars. On their left free ends, the 8 knots that came undone averaged 0.721 mm per strike over a whole trial. At that rate a loop of 165.2 mm lasts 229 strikes, so the model lets a 3 g knot hold until then. Lighter weights never reach that pull, which matches the arm’s rear strikes. For Fig. 2 the model supposes that a stride is one strike and that walking pulls on a free end as hard as the 3 g weights did. The paper says it could not measure how the loops and free ends move on a real shoe.
Reef way or granny way
The strong bow and the weak one differ only in the second crossing. Tied opposite to the first, it makes the strong knot, based on the square or reef knot. Tied the same way, it makes the weak one, based on the granny knot, also called the false or granary knot. To tighten, the weak knot must twist completely. Fieggen describes where that twist leaves the bow. Each half turns it a little. Tied opposite ways the turns cancel and the loops lie across the shoe; tied the same way they add, and the loops lie along it from heel to toe.
Pick a way of tying the second crossing in Fig. 4, and guess where its loops will point once they are pulled tight.
What the drawing shows
The granny loops end a quarter turn round, lying along the shoe, while the reef loops stay across it. On the paper’s arm, with 3 g weights and rear strikes, every weak knot came undone, at about four times the strong knot’s slip. Walked as in Fig. 2, the model’s granny knot gives way at stride 56. Why it is weaker the authors could not prove. They suspect the twist. Fieggen, writing on his own site, puts it down to the way the touching parts of the two crossings pull on each other. A. Hyatt Verrill’s book of knots calls the granny “a most useless, bothersome, and deceptive makeshift”.
Laces before the laboratory
In 2008 a laced leather shoe was found in the Areni-1 cave in Armenia. Its leather is radiocarbon dated to 3627 to 3377 BC. A leather thong was stitched through 15 sets of eyelets along its top. Its finders call it the oldest shoe from Eurasia, and expect still older footwear. Their paper does not say how the thong’s ends were tied.
Patents show people fighting the loose bow long before 2017. In 1893 Cornelia F. Hathaway of San Francisco patented a clamp for “the bow or other slip-knot” of shoestrings. In 1900 William Lester Lee of Iola, Kansas, patented a fastener to hold a lace “against being accidentally untied or loosened by the action of the foot”. People still ask about it online, in user reports. Someone on r/explainlikeimfive asked why laces loosen however tight they are tied. The reply that scored highest said its writer learned only at 40 that they had been tying theirs wrong. A walker on Lifehacks Stack Exchange wrote of retying their laces as often as every 10 minutes. Seymour Taft’s patent of 1938 put beads along a lace to stop its ends “pulling through the knot”, the failure the paper filmed 79 years later.
What the drawings leave out
The sizes are the drawing’s own. Only two follow the paper: the loops and free ends start at its 82.6 mm, and Fig. 3’s arm has its length and angle. No source gives the eyelets, the knot centre, the way the free ends lie or the pendulum’s block and stop. The drawings lay a bow flat and show each lace as one line. Only the left free end slips in Fig. 2, because the paper’s rear-struck knots failed mostly on the left lace.
The model’s slips come from the paper’s bar charts, read to within about 0.002 mm per strike. Its walking is a supposition, and under it the granny knot goes in under a minute. The paper’s runner ran for several minutes first. Fieggen also criticised the test: in rear strikes the hanging ends hit the knot’s block and the arm, and the laces entering the knot stayed straight, while a shoe’s upper flexes at every step. The paper did not test other laces. O’Reilly and Daily-Diamond said their own laces still came untied at least once a day.
Sources
Read in November 2026.
- C. A. Daily-Diamond, C. E. Gregg and O. M. O’Reilly, “The roles of impact and inertia in the failure of a shoelace knot”, Proceedings of the Royal Society A, 2017, read in its PubMed Central copy: the account, the tests and every measured number. Bar heights are taken from its figures 9 and 13.
- O. M. O’Reilly, talk abstract at ETH Zurich: three years of spare time.
- Brett Israel, Berkeley News, 11 April 2017: Gregg on the treadmill, and Daily-Diamond’s words.
- California magazine, fall 2017: the daughter’s question, the borrowed camera, and laces still coming untied.
- Ian Fieggen, Ian’s Shoelace Site, “The Granny Knot” and “Granny Knot Study”. User report.
- A. Hyatt Verrill, “Knots, Splices and Rope Work”, Project Gutenberg.
- R. Pinhasi and others, the Areni-1 shoe, PLoS ONE, 2010.
- Cornelia F. Hathaway, US Patent 500,497, “Shoe-lace fastener”, 1893.
- William Lester Lee, US Patent 657,606, “Shoe-lace fastener”, 1900.
- Seymour Taft, US Patent 2,141,801, “Shoelace”, 1938: its words only.
- Wikipedia, “Shoelace knot”, for one of the bow’s names.
- r/explainlikeimfive, “ELI5: Why shoelaces tend to losen themselves no matter how tight we tight them?”, November 2016, via the Arctic Shift archive. User report.
- Lifehacks Stack Exchange, “How to keep shoes from coming untied?”, October 2015. User report.
- International Guild of Knot Tyers forum, “Knot test report: shoelace failure analysis”, December 2018. User report.
The type is Playpen Sans by TypeTogether, under the SIL Open Font License 1.1.