Toilet
Water stands in a toilet bowl because the pipe behind it climbs before it falls to the drain. Pour a little in and it spills over the top of that bend. Pour a lot in fast and the bend fills and starts a siphon, which empties the bowl. Then the cistern refills and shuts itself off.
The bend behind the bowl
Behind the bowl of a siphon water-closet, the outlet climbs as an up-leg and crosses a dam. Past the dam it drops as a down-leg to the drain under the floor. The bowl’s back wall reaches down into the water and stops short of the bottom. A 1911 patent by Arthur William Cooksey of London calls that lower edge the dip. Fig. 1 follows the closet that Winfield E. Hinsdale, a New Yorker, patented in 1901.
Water poured into an empty bowl runs under the dip and up the up-leg until it reaches the top of the dam. There it stops rising, because anything more spills over and falls away. So a bowl at rest is always full to the height of its dam. The water standing between the dip and the dam closes the way from the drain. In the drawing that seal is 60 mm deep.
Not every bowl siphons. A washdown bowl is cleared by the force of the flush alone. Siphon bowls are found mainly in North American homes. This page draws Hinsdale’s siphon bowl. Guess which of the three pours in Fig. 1 will empty the bowl.
Slow and fast pours
A bucket of six litres goes into the drawing’s bowl at one of three rates. Half a litre a second is a slow pour. Four litres a second is the bucket tipped in at once. Water leaves over the dam faster the higher the bowl stands above it, by the rule for a broad-crested weir. The stream crossing the dam is two-thirds as deep as the bowl stands above it. The drawing’s siphon starts once that stream is as deep as the passage is tall, so that it fills the bend to its roof.
What the drawing shows
Only the bucket tipped in starts the siphon. Poured slowly, the bowl rises 29 mm above the dam and no higher, because water then leaves over the dam as fast as it comes in. All six litres go through and leave the bowl as full as before. At a litre and a half a second it climbs to 57 mm, still short of the 75 mm that makes the stream as deep as the passage. Tipped in, the bucket lifts the bowl that high in 1.1 seconds, with 4.5 litres in. Then the bend runs full. The water falling down the down-leg pulls the water behind it. The siphon drains the bowl at 3.6 to 4.7 litres a second, faster than the bucket pours.
One answer on Home Improvement Stack Exchange, a user report, describes the same test. Pour slowly from a bucket and even a sound toilet flushes badly; throw the water in hard and it should flush at once and leave little water behind. In Hinsdale’s patent, curves in the down-leg slow the falling water, so that a small flush fills it and keeps air from below away from the top of the bend. The drawing’s bend fills by speed alone. In this drawing no steady pour under 2.1 litres a second can start the siphon, however long it goes on.
When air gets under the dip
The siphon runs until the bowl’s surface falls to the dip. Air then passes under the back wall into the bend. The column breaks and the flow stops. That is the gurgle at the end of a flush. In Fig. 1 this happens 2.65 seconds after the bucket starts to pour. The water left stands level with the dip, so air can pass over it, and the seal is gone.
A siphon bowl therefore needs more water after its flush, or the drain’s air can reach the room. Henry C. Weeden’s patent of 1890 gives his bowl a chamber that keeps back part of the flushing water and lets it out slowly. He wanted it to raise the level left in the bowl after the siphon has broken. Fluidmaster’s fill valves send water through a refill tube to the overflow pipe for the same job. Fig. 4 shows that tube at work.
What the seal holds back
The Water Supply (Water Fittings) Regulations 1999, which apply in England and Wales, define a trap as “a pipe fitting, or part of a sanitary appliance, that retains liquid to prevent the passage of foul air”. In 1775 Alexander Cumming, a Scottish watchmaker, obtained the first UK patent for a flushing water closet, and it centred on an S-shaped trap. His S-pipe cut smells by keeping water in the pipe. The patent also asked for a trap whose contents could be emptied every time the closet was used.
Air in a drain can push. Fig. 2 is the bend of Fig. 1 with air pressing on it from the drain side. The push is measured as the height of a column of water it could hold up. Guess how hard the air must press to get through a seal 60 mm deep.
What the drawing shows
The air must press a little harder than the seal is deep, with 69 mm of water, about 675 pascals, in the drawing. As the surface in the bend sinks, the water it gives up goes into the bowl. The bowl’s surface is nearly seven times the bend’s, so it rises only a seventh as far. The push holds up the difference between the two surfaces. That difference must reach the seal’s depth plus the bowl’s rise before air gets to the dip.
Letting the cistern go
The cistern, which Americans call the tank, holds the water for one flush above the bowl. Fig. 3 is drawn after the flush tank in William L. Harroun’s patent of 1921. A pipe leads from the cistern’s floor down to the bowl, and its top edge is a seat. On the seat sits the flush valve, which in Harroun’s patent is a hollow ball of rubber. It sits on the seat by its own weight, the patent says, and seals the pipe. The handle turns a lever inside the cistern, and the lever lifts the ball.
Off its seat, the ball floats. Harroun wrote that, being buoyant, it is held away from its seat until near the end of the flush, when the water rushing out draws it back down. He also wrote that a ball tipped on its seat lets water go on running out like a leak. A rubber flapper holds water in the tank and lets it into the bowl when the toilet is flushed. Traditional flappers are held open the same way, by air.
In Fig. 3 the handle is pressed at the start and let go after half a second. Guess whether the ball drops back when the handle does.
What the drawing shows
The ball goes on floating after the lever has dropped back. It rides down with the falling water and sits back on its seat 2.12 seconds after the press, with the water 59 mm deep and 5.5 litres gone to the bowl. Through the open seat the drawing’s water leaves at up to 3.1 litres a second. The bowl in Fig. 1 needs more than 2.1 litres a second before its siphon can start.
Filling up and shutting off
As the water falls, so does the float of the fill valve. In the flush tank of a 1904 patent by William A. Henn and Jacob B. Henn, the float’s buoyancy holds the ball-cock’s valve shut. As water flows out, the float descends and lets the valve open. The outflow is far greater than the inflow, the patent says, so the tank still empties. Fig. 4 begins the moment the ball is back on its seat, with the bowl left at the dip by its siphon. Guess whether the cistern or the bowl is full first.
What the drawing shows
The bowl is full first. The drawing’s refill tube takes 30% of what the fill valve lets in, and that brings the bowl from the dip back up to the dam in 29 seconds. Whatever comes after spills over the dam. The cistern goes on filling for longer. Once the water is within about 10 mm of the full mark, the rising float starts to close the valve, the flow slows, and the valve shuts 52 seconds after the flush with the cistern 160 mm deep.
Lemuel Prosser’s patent of 1777 already used a floating valve to regulate the water in the tank. Thomas Crapper held nine patents, one of them for a ballcock. He did not invent the toilet. His advertising implied the siphon flush was his own.
A cistern that keeps running
With the worn ball in Fig. 4, the cistern never quite fills. Water seeps past the ball all the time, so the float stays a little low. The valve stays 1.8% open and lets water in as fast as it leaks out. The drawing loses about 308 litres a day. An old or worn flapper can make a toilet flush on its own, or leak thousands of gallons a year without a sound.
Users on Home Improvement Stack Exchange describe two such leaks, in user reports. One wrote of a toilet that ran for a few seconds every few minutes, after a new flapper and float. The accepted answer said that if the water is not high enough to go down the overflow, it must be seeping past the flapper. Another found that the hose into the overflow pipe went in too far and was siphoning water out of the tank.
A toilet that refills by itself, every few minutes or every few hours, is losing water. Its sound is called ghost flushing. Inside the cistern the cause can be a worn flapper, a damaged seat under it, or a refill tube pushed into the overflow pipe, which can siphon water out.
How much one flush may use
Rules on flush volume belong to particular countries, and they are rules of different kinds. In the United States the EPA’s WaterSense Specification for Tank-Type Toilets sets the bar for a label. Version 2.0, of May 2024, took effect on 1 July 2025. Its section 3.1 says the maker’s rated flush volume “shall not exceed 1.28 gallons per flush (gpf; 4.8 liters per flush [Lpf])”, and section 3.2 puts both flushes of a dual-flush toilet under the same limit.
In England and Wales the Water Supply (Water Fittings) Regulations 1999 set a limit in law. Until 1 January 2001, paragraph 25(5) of Schedule 2 set it at 7.5 litres and asked for a flushing cistern “of the valveless type which incorporates siphonic apparatus”. Paragraph 25(1)(d) now reads: “no flushing device installed for use with a WC pan shall give a single flush exceeding 6 litres”. Paragraph 25(1)(e) holds the smaller flush of a dual-flush device to two-thirds of the larger.
The drawing’s cistern lets 5.5 litres go. Fig. 1’s bucket holds 6 litres, the limit in England and Wales.
What the drawings leave out
The sizes are the drawing’s own. So is every number worked out from them. Hinsdale’s outlet has curves in its down-leg, and his bowl has a jet. His passage is at least three and a half inches across. The drawing’s passage is narrower and its down-leg plain, with no jet and no flushing rim, and it takes the bowl’s plan to be an oval.
The flow rules are textbook rules for weirs and orifices from the Water Measurement Manual, with its coefficient of 0.61. Real bends are rounder. The siphon’s start is the drawing’s own rule, where real bowls start theirs with jets and shaped passages.
In the cistern, the drawing lifts the ball on a chain where Harroun used rods. Its overflow pipe and refill tube follow Fluidmaster’s pages, and it leaves out the guides that keep a ball over its seat. Water appears only as the line of its surface and as arrows.
Sources
Read in November 2026.
- W. E. Hinsdale, US Patent 670,588, 26 March 1901: his siphon water-closet. Fig. 1 and Fig. 2 are drawn after its figure.
- A. W. Cooksey, US Patent 1,008,787, 14 November 1911: a siphonic closet, for the word dip.
- H. C. Weeden, US Patent 441,268, 25 November 1890: a bowl that refills after its siphon breaks.
- W. L. Harroun, US Patent 1,374,655, 12 April 1921: a floating rubber ball. Fig. 3 and Fig. 4 are drawn after its first figure.
- W. A. Henn and J. B. Henn, US Patent 762,405, 14 June 1904: a flush tank and its ball-cock.
- US Environmental Protection Agency, WaterSense Specification for Tank-Type Toilets, version 2.0, May 2024, sections 1.0, 3.1 and 3.2.
- EPA WaterSense, Fix a Leak Week, on worn flappers.
- The Water Supply (Water Fittings) Regulations 1999, Schedule 2, paragraph 25, on legislation.gov.uk.
- The National Archives, Innovations in toilet design, on Cumming and Prosser.
- Kerry Grist, Science Museum blog, “A flushing story”, 5 November 2020.
- Fluidmaster, its pages on refilling: flappers, refill tubes and ghost flushing.
- US Bureau of Reclamation, Water Measurement Manual: broad-crested weirs and submerged orifices.
- Wikipedia, “Flush toilet”, on washdown bowls, where siphon bowls are found, and the gurgle.
- Home Improvement Stack Exchange, “How do I fix a slow toilet flush?” and an answer, January 2013. User report.
- Home Improvement Stack Exchange, “Why is toilet running every few minutes?” and the answer its asker accepted, January 2023. User report.
- Home Improvement Stack Exchange, “Water keeps draining into the toilet when the float valve shuts off”, June 2024, and an answer of December 2024. User report.
The type is Playpen Sans by TypeTogether, under the SIL Open Font License 1.1.